Author Topic:  Indonesia detector shops and counterfeit minelabs and coiltek coils.  (Read 1344 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

golddigger

  • Guest
Hi all  :D


I am going to indonesia in less than two weeks am and just wondering, does anybody know of metal detecting shops around Bali or Yogjarkarta??

Thanks!     Help would be FANTASTIC!

 :D :D
« Last Edit: March 25, 2012, 17:38 by Rwork »

Offline Rwork

  • Moderator
  • Platinum
  • *
  • Member Since: Mar 2010
  • Posts: 12339

  • Last 30 Days Activity
    100%
    • I live in: Swan Hill. Nth.Vic
  • Likes Given: 34
Re:Indonesia detector shops and fakes.
« Reply #1 on: March 24, 2012, 18:37 »
I see 2 guest viewing this OLD post. I thought i might add another link to the end of it.



http://forum.kimbucktwo.com/index.php/topic,7368.0.html
« Last Edit: March 25, 2012, 17:39 by Rwork »
  • Detector(s) owned/used: Owned,Two Mlb 5000. Sovs,GT and XS,Ace 250.Waiting on the Minelab long pulse Pro series.
  • Oldest find: Ancient gold and 1797 cartwheel penny.
  • My Awards Awarded for winning a leg of "Play it forward" Award for finding a gold nugget Awarded for finding a Penny Award for finding a Florin Award for finding a threepence Award for finding a sixpence Award for finding a Half Penny

  • Offline Rwork

    • Moderator
    • Platinum
    • *
    • Member Since: Mar 2010
    • Posts: 12339

    • Last 30 Days Activity
      100%
      • I live in: Swan Hill. Nth.Vic
    • Likes Given: 34
    « Last Edit: March 25, 2012, 17:40 by Rwork »
    • Detector(s) owned/used: Owned,Two Mlb 5000. Sovs,GT and XS,Ace 250.Waiting on the Minelab long pulse Pro series.
    • Oldest find: Ancient gold and 1797 cartwheel penny.
  • My Awards Awarded for winning a leg of "Play it forward" Award for finding a gold nugget Awarded for finding a Penny Award for finding a Florin Award for finding a threepence Award for finding a sixpence Award for finding a Half Penny

  • Offline lxss5000

    • Platinum
    • *****
    • Member Since: May 2010
    • Posts: 1240
    • CTX 3030 here I come. Didnt JOHN WAYNE use a 3030?

    • Last 30 Days Activity
      0.83%
    • Likes Given: 0
    Re: Indonesia detector shops and Fakes.
    « Reply #3 on: March 24, 2012, 20:21 »
    « Last Edit: March 25, 2012, 17:41 by Rwork »
    • Detector(s) owned/used: Minelab CTX3030, Etrac
    • Oldest find: George III Half penny date unreadable aprox 200years old
  • My Awards Award for returning a lost valuable to original owner Awarded when you have found a 1/2d, 1d, 3d, 6d, 1/-, 2/- Awarded for winning a leg of "Play it forward" Award for finding a gold ring
  • 2013 Goal $1000, 50 silver coins, 24 dog tags
    5Gold items  20 Silver items
    Modern$=14.57
    Florin=
    Shilling=
    6pence=1
    3pence= 1
    silver coins=2
    Gold jewelry items=
    Silver jewelry items= 1
    Dog tags=

    Offline wetfeet

    • Gold
    • ****
    • Member Since: Jan 2012
    • Posts: 757
    • Who dares wins

    • Last 30 Days Activity
      0%
    • Likes Given: 0
    Re: Indonesia detecting shops and Fakes.
    « Reply #4 on: March 24, 2012, 20:34 »
    Geez that list of counterfeiters and dodgy sellers is huge  :o




    wetfeet
    « Last Edit: March 25, 2012, 17:42 by Rwork »
    • Oldest find: 1867 Queen Victoria penny
  • My Awards Awarded for the best non-coin find each month (voted by users) Awarded when you have found a 1/2d, 1d, 3d, 6d, 1/-, 2/- Award for finding a gold ring

  • Offline scratchinaround

    • Platinum
    • *****
    • Member Since: Oct 2011
    • Posts: 1800

    • Last 30 Days Activity
      65%
      • I live in: a land of confusion.
    • Likes Given: 58
    Re: Indonesia Detector shops and Fakes.
    « Reply #5 on: March 24, 2012, 23:52 »
     :o :o :o   wow on the ball there RWORK!   good work.  cheap is rarely  CHEAP. warranty? nah. quality tested product? nah. pay  the extra and all,s  good. so  many  scams, so many suckers  :o  read the papers, the net. too cheap, too bad. many have the 1-2 warranty. once you buy it,   two - ^%$# bad. a bit like  fleebay mbe. ::)                              8)
    « Last Edit: March 25, 2012, 17:43 by Rwork »
    • Detector(s) owned/used: used bh discovery 33oo, ace350,m/l 305. now tesoro compadre
    • Oldest find: 1923 sa football members badge,1902/5/6dog reg tags.1910 bottle,66 round 50 cent.1912 farthing.1927h/penny1857/81penny
  • My Awards Award for finding a Florin Award for finding a threepence Award for finding a sixpence Award for finding a gold ring Awarded for finding a Penny Award for finding a Half Penny Award for finding a farthing or part farthing.
  • HOT  DIGGERTY DIG

    Offline Snoopy36

    • Platinum
    • *****
    • Member Since: Jan 2010
    • Posts: 3694

    • Last 30 Days Activity
      0%
      • Youtube channel
    • Likes Given: 8
    Re: Indonesia detector shops and Fakes.
    « Reply #6 on: March 25, 2012, 08:06 »
    You can get really really good chocolate in Yogyakarta :)  It's called Choclat Monggo available at Mirota Batik. Trust me it's the best chocolate you'll ever taste.

    Metal detectors? Nah don't do it :)
    « Last Edit: March 25, 2012, 17:43 by Rwork »
    • Detector(s) owned/used: Minelab XTerra 705, Sovereign GT
    • Oldest find: 1857 Gold Half Sovereign
  • My Awards Awarded to whoever finds the best coin each month Award for finding a Half Sovereign Awarded for finding an Australian Rising Sun Badge Awarded when you have found a 1/2d, 1d, 3d, 6d, 1/-, 2/- Award for finding a gold ring Award for returning a lost valuable to original owner
  • SuperSnoopy36 on YouTube!

    www.youtube.com/supersnoopy36

    Offline Aussie Detecting

    • Platinum
    • *****
    • Member Since: Jul 2010
    • Posts: 1356
    • www.aussiedetectors.com

    • Last 30 Days Activity
      0%
      • I live in: Bendigo Vic
      • Aussie Detecting & Prospecting
    • Likes Given: 0
    Re: Indonesia Detecting shops and Fakes.
    « Reply #7 on: March 25, 2012, 08:10 »
    Best to take your own. Don't you worry the fakes don't stop with minelab. Garrett, fisher, whites, you name it they will fake it. Mongrels.
    « Last Edit: March 25, 2012, 17:44 by Rwork »
    • Detector(s) owned/used: Too many.
    • Oldest find: Roman coin
  • My Awards Awarded for finding a Penny Award for finding a Half Penny
  • It's all about having fun.
    www.aussiedetectors.com

    Offline lxss5000

    • Platinum
    • *****
    • Member Since: May 2010
    • Posts: 1240
    • CTX 3030 here I come. Didnt JOHN WAYNE use a 3030?

    • Last 30 Days Activity
      0.83%
    • Likes Given: 0
    Re: Indonesia detecting shops and fakes.
    « Reply #8 on: March 25, 2012, 09:14 »
    We should make a counterfeit thread and pin What do you think Mods???

     it here is another form Coiltec

    http://coiltekmanufacturing.com.au/counterfeitcoil.html
    « Last Edit: March 25, 2012, 17:45 by Rwork »
    • Detector(s) owned/used: Minelab CTX3030, Etrac
    • Oldest find: George III Half penny date unreadable aprox 200years old
  • My Awards Award for returning a lost valuable to original owner Awarded when you have found a 1/2d, 1d, 3d, 6d, 1/-, 2/- Awarded for winning a leg of "Play it forward" Award for finding a gold ring
  • 2013 Goal $1000, 50 silver coins, 24 dog tags
    5Gold items  20 Silver items
    Modern$=14.57
    Florin=
    Shilling=
    6pence=1
    3pence= 1
    silver coins=2
    Gold jewelry items=
    Silver jewelry items= 1
    Dog tags=

    Offline Rwork

    • Moderator
    • Platinum
    • *
    • Member Since: Mar 2010
    • Posts: 12339

    • Last 30 Days Activity
      100%
      • I live in: Swan Hill. Nth.Vic
    • Likes Given: 34
    Re: Indonesia detecting shops and Fakes.
    « Reply #9 on: March 25, 2012, 17:36 »
    This post got off track a little,i wonder did golddigger go, and did he find a shop. No member golddigger any more,just similar names.
    Re counterfeit, this one probably covers it,i will change the header name a little.
    « Last Edit: March 25, 2012, 17:45 by Rwork »
    • Detector(s) owned/used: Owned,Two Mlb 5000. Sovs,GT and XS,Ace 250.Waiting on the Minelab long pulse Pro series.
    • Oldest find: Ancient gold and 1797 cartwheel penny.
  • My Awards Awarded for winning a leg of "Play it forward" Award for finding a gold nugget Awarded for finding a Penny Award for finding a Florin Award for finding a threepence Award for finding a sixpence Award for finding a Half Penny

  • Offline Son of the Sands

    • Silver
    • ***
    • Member Since: Jan 2012
    • Posts: 469

    • Last 30 Days Activity
      0%
      • I live in: Blackpool, United Kingdom
    • Likes Given: 0
    So, I know this mught sound a daft question, but do these counterfeiters just copy the design? Or do they copy the circuitry as well. If you buy one of these things is a good way to test it to stand on a car and see if it makes a noise?
    • Detector(s) owned/used: Minelab CTX3030, Garrett Treasure Ace
    • Oldest find: Roman coins, Celtic stater
  • My Awards Awarded for finding an Australian Rising Sun Badge Award for finding a gold ring Awarded when you have found a 1/2d, 1d, 3d, 6d, 1/-, 2/-

  • Offline scratchinaround

    • Platinum
    • *****
    • Member Since: Oct 2011
    • Posts: 1800

    • Last 30 Days Activity
      65%
      • I live in: a land of confusion.
    • Likes Given: 58
    So, I know this mught sound a daft question, but do these counterfeiters just copy the design? Or do they copy the circuitry as well. If you buy one of these things is a good way to test it to stand on a car and see if it makes a noise?
      hi SOS. i would think that all brands use the same  or  similar components, ie  asia.
     we don,t make any thing here in aust. for minelab circuitry etc do we?  they too are made O/S are,nt they?  funny tho, the chinese GC/ GOLD SNOOPS etc get some good reviews.  cheers. ;)
    • Detector(s) owned/used: used bh discovery 33oo, ace350,m/l 305. now tesoro compadre
    • Oldest find: 1923 sa football members badge,1902/5/6dog reg tags.1910 bottle,66 round 50 cent.1912 farthing.1927h/penny1857/81penny
  • My Awards Award for finding a Florin Award for finding a threepence Award for finding a sixpence Award for finding a gold ring Awarded for finding a Penny Award for finding a Half Penny Award for finding a farthing or part farthing.
  • HOT  DIGGERTY DIG

    Offline Son of the Sands

    • Silver
    • ***
    • Member Since: Jan 2012
    • Posts: 469

    • Last 30 Days Activity
      0%
      • I live in: Blackpool, United Kingdom
    • Likes Given: 0
    I think Minelabs are made in Malaysia from what I hear.
    • Detector(s) owned/used: Minelab CTX3030, Garrett Treasure Ace
    • Oldest find: Roman coins, Celtic stater
  • My Awards Awarded for finding an Australian Rising Sun Badge Award for finding a gold ring Awarded when you have found a 1/2d, 1d, 3d, 6d, 1/-, 2/-

  • groundfisher

    • Guest
    When the counterfeit manufacturers start copying a product they start out making exact copies even making them as good as the original, they then set about reducing the quality of the parts and manufacturing until they get to the point that they last for 12 months and no more, that then becomes their standard for manufacturing.

    Example:
    When Japan started making electronics they were the worst in the world, they achieved sales but soon realised that they needed to improve quality or they would not sell product, they not only improved their standards but set new highs for standards and now Japanese electronics is considered the best.

    Malaysia and other countries in that region are at the point where they know they need to lift their game or lose sales to China.

    China is at just past the start of the cycle, they are at the point of reducing quality until they can manufacture it the cheapest, people are starting to realise that Chinese products are crap and at some point China will have to lift their game or some other country like India will start the copy cycle.

    The metal detectors being counterfeited would likely have circuit boards and parts that are identical to the genuine ones.
    Some manufacturers will have substituted the internals for some that will give the appearance of working properly and will even detect metal but won't be the same as the other manufacturers, they will find sales falling as the better fakes take the market.
    The manufacturers that make identical copies of the original won't have all the knowledge of the genuine product so won't know what fine internal adjustments to make to have it operating within original specifications, they will also choose cheaper parts that may not have the correct tolerance so the circuit won't perform as it should.

    Take the Xterra 705 for example, the copy will still detect metal, have all the menu's, settings etc but it won't perform as well as a genuine one.
    When you set the threshold the copy won't be producing the same output as the original, when setting discrimination patterns the copy might discriminate out more than just what you set it to or less.
    When you swap coils the copy might not use the correct frequency for that coil or it may not recognise that a coil has been connected.


    Offline eljay

    • Platinum
    • *****
    • Member Since: Jan 2012
    • Posts: 1290

    • Last 30 Days Activity
      0%
      • I live in: Morayfield Queensland
    • Likes Given: 0
    Hi all  :D


    I am going to indonesia in less than two weeks am and just wondering, does anybody know of metal detecting shops around Bali or Yogjarkarta??

    Thanks!     Help would be FANTASTIC!

     :D :D

    In answer to your original question, i don't think you will find one and if you do the machines they sell will not be worth the investment, consider for a moment that the average local only earns about 42000 rupiah a month about $30 OZ, and something like the XTerra would cost them around 1650000 rupiah, only millionaires in Bali could afford such a machine.
    • Detector(s) owned/used: X-TERRA 705, Garrett Propointer, Garrett AT PRO, Garrett Seahunter Mark II
    • Oldest find: 1873 English Bun Head Penny
  • My Awards Awarded for finding an Australian Rising Sun Badge Awarded when you have found a 1/2d, 1d, 3d, 6d, 1/-, 2/- Award for finding a farthing or part farthing. Award for finding a gold ring

  • Offline Aussie Detecting

    • Platinum
    • *****
    • Member Since: Jul 2010
    • Posts: 1356
    • www.aussiedetectors.com

    • Last 30 Days Activity
      0%
      • I live in: Bendigo Vic
      • Aussie Detecting & Prospecting
    • Likes Given: 0
    Eljay you make a good point. An exciting & scary point. Imagine all the goodies on the beaches due to the fact that detectors are so expensive that hardly anyone has one. On the other hand you be watched by everyone including shady characters. Your detector will make a great target to be taken.
    • Detector(s) owned/used: Too many.
    • Oldest find: Roman coin
  • My Awards Awarded for finding a Penny Award for finding a Half Penny
  • It's all about having fun.
    www.aussiedetectors.com

    Offline eljay

    • Platinum
    • *****
    • Member Since: Jan 2012
    • Posts: 1290

    • Last 30 Days Activity
      0%
      • I live in: Morayfield Queensland
    • Likes Given: 0
    Eljay you make a good point. An exciting & scary point. Imagine all the goodies on the beaches due to the fact that detectors are so expensive that hardly anyone has one. On the other hand you be watched by everyone including shady characters. Your detector will make a great target to be taken.

    That's right, there are those who do take MD's to Bali though, you can google search and find forums with info, basically it's ok with the Indonesian authorities according to the Indonesian consulate here in OZ, but you will be questioned about what it is, and why you have it on arrival.
    next forget taking a VLF machine it's PI country only due to high mineralization on the beaches, the black sand at Sanur can be picked up with a magnet, you will have local kids following you around who apparently call out what it is you have found, it is said that large groups detecting on the beaches are targeted by local police and detectors have been confiscated. all in all i reckon it might be better to enjoy the local highlights and give detecting a rest for awhile.
    • Detector(s) owned/used: X-TERRA 705, Garrett Propointer, Garrett AT PRO, Garrett Seahunter Mark II
    • Oldest find: 1873 English Bun Head Penny
  • My Awards Awarded for finding an Australian Rising Sun Badge Awarded when you have found a 1/2d, 1d, 3d, 6d, 1/-, 2/- Award for finding a farthing or part farthing. Award for finding a gold ring

  •  

    @MEMBER OF PROJECT HONEY POT
    Spam Harvester Protection Network
    provided by Unspam